Sampling decisions for quantifying soil carbon change: resampling the same locations increases efficiency and precision
DOI:
Loading...
Abstract
Quantifying changes in soil carbon commonly relies on sampling designs that either return to new or the same locations in the project area. When the intention is to quantify change caused by adoption of different management practices, these same approaches are used but complemented with control areas that function as counterfactual, business-as-usual conditions. For both monitoring and causal estimation, a key design decision underpins the efficiency and precision of a sampling campaign: whether to 1) resample an independent set of samples or 2) resample the same point locations (paired resampling). Using repeated measurements of soil carbon concentrations and stocks from 796 locations across 80 agricultural fields distributed across 20 strata, we first evaluate the sampling efficiency and precision benefits of paired resampling within a monitoring context. In monitoring, we find that resampling the same point locations resulted in an ~2.5-times improvement in precision, which translated to gains in sampling efficiency of 6.7- and 5.5-times fewer samples required to detect change in soil carbon concentrations and stocks, respectively. For causal estimation, where more factors generate uncertainty in the change estimate, paired resampling improved precision by 1.75- and 1.95-times and sampling efficiencies by 3.1- and 3.8-times for concentrations and stocks. Our results are consistent with directional expectations from sampling theory that revisiting sampling locations provides gains in precision and efficiency for quantifying change. However, by testing this theory with a large empirical dataset, we reveal that theoretical benefits translate to real-world, practical benefits of paired resampling designs for overcoming noise generated by the large size and high variability of soil carbon contents to detect the signal of soil carbon change. Our results are relevant for informing the efficiency and precision of designs for regional and national programs focused on tracking and improving soil conditions for soil health, food security and climate mitigation.
Environmental Defense Fund
M.A.N. Baker and G.L. Baker, Jr.
Yale Center for Natural Carbon Capture
None
November 18, 2026